Understanding American Express Chargeback Reason Code M10: Vehicle Rental – Capital Damages

American Express Reason Code M10 applies to vehicle rentals when a cardholder disputes a charge for capital damages, theft, or loss of use. It often arises from disagreement over liability or the amount billed. The issue is whether the merchant followed the agreement, properly documented the incident, and billed correctly.

Key Takeaways

• What it means: A dispute over charges for vehicle damage, theft, or loss of use on a rental.
• Causes: Liability disagreements. Incorrect amounts. Poor documentation. Late cancellations.
• How to respond: Submit detailed evidence including photos and invoices within the time limit.
• How to prevent: Use clear contracts. Take pre- and post-hire photos. Keep estimates and invoices.

What is an American Express Reason Code M10 Chargeback?

Reason Code M10 is used when a cardholder challenges a charge linked to a vehicle rental for capital damages, theft, or loss of use. In simple terms, a customer says, “I did not agree to this bill,” or “the amount is wrong,” after a rental car incident. The dispute focuses on liability and how the charge was calculated.

In most cases, the rental agreement sets out what the renter must pay if the vehicle is damaged, stolen, or unavailable for further hire. The renter may also have bought extra cover or declined it. A key test is that the charge must not exceed 110% of the amount stated or agreed in the contract for capital damages.

In short, a Reason Code M10 chargeback is a formal challenge. It asks the merchant and issuer to prove that the cardholder accepted liability. And it requires that the amount charged for damage, theft, or loss of use was correctly calculated and supported by evidence.

Primary Causes for a Code M10 Chargeback

Disputes under M10 usually arise from a mismatch between expectations and the rental contract. One common cause is the belief that a third party would pay. A cardholder might assume that a damage waiver, workplace travel policy, or personal insurance would cover the bill, only to find it does not apply as they thought. When the merchant charges the card, the cardholder then disputes liability.

Another frequent trigger is the amount billed. If the total differs from an itemised invoice given to the customer, or from the figure stated in the rental terms, the cardholder may claim the charge is wrong. M10 also appears when the charge exceeds 110% of the sum the customer agreed to in relation to capital damages, or when the repair estimate seems inflated.

Documentation problems often worsen matters. If there are no dated photos before and after the hire, or no signed inspection reports, the cardholder may argue that damage was pre-existing. Timing issues also feature: a customer who tried to cancel on time, or who submitted a cancellation that was processed late, might reject a related charge. Finally, poor communication about loss of use or storage fees can lead to disputes over what was agreed and what was actually owed.

Time Limit for Disputing an American Express Reason Code M10 Chargeback

American Express sets a tight timetable for responding to M10. The acquirer or merchant has 20 days to submit a response. That window is not all yours: it includes the time the acquirer takes to notify you and to pass your materials to American Express. In practice, that can leave only a few days for you to assemble and send your evidence.

Because the time limit is short, speed is essential. As soon as a dispute arrives, retrieve the signed rental agreement (with the capital damages clause). Pull the handover and return inspection reports, date-stamped photos, repair estimates, and invoice. If the charge relates to theft or loss of use, include a police report if available and the calculation that shows how you assessed downtime. If you have already issued a credit, include the credit memo and processing details.

Missing the deadline usually means the chargeback stands, regardless of the merits. Set internal targets that are stricter than the American Express deadline, and keep evidence organised. The best way to meet the time limit is to prepare your document set on the day you first learn of the dispute.

What M10 Means for Consumers & Issuers

For consumers, M10 is a way to challenge charges that feel unfair or unexpected after a vehicle rental. It covers three situations: capital damages to the vehicle, theft while in the renter’s possession, and loss of use while the vehicle is out of service. The contract is central. If the signed agreement makes the cardholder responsible and the amount is calculated according to those terms, the charge is more likely to stand. If not, the dispute may succeed. Clear evidence helps a consumer case. This may be photos taken at pick-up and drop-off, emails to the rental desk, or any waivers or insurance confirmations.

For issuers, M10 requires a balanced review of liability and pricing under the rental agreement. Issuers look for proof that the cardholder accepted responsibility, that the merchant presented itemised charges, and that the total falls within policy limits, especially the 110% rule for capital damages. Issuers also weigh the relevance of any credits already issued and the timing of the cancellation, if that is part of the complaint. The objective is a fair outcome based on the contract and the evidence, not on assumptions about insurance or the renter’s expectations.

What M10 Means for Merchants

For merchants, an M10 chargeback tests how well your rental process is documented and priced. The financial impact can go beyond the dispute amount. You may face chargeback fees, staff time spent on evidence gathering, and a higher dispute ratio that can affect your terms with payment partners. Poor results can also harm customer trust if complaints circulate about “surprise” damage bills.

A strong defence starts at the counter. Contracts should spell out the customer’s liability for damage, theft, and loss of use in plain language. Inspections at pick-up and return should be completed with the renter present, recorded on a signed form, and backed by clear, date-stamped photos. Where feasible, use consistent lighting and angles for clarity. When damage occurs, compile repair estimates from reputable suppliers and charge only in line with the agreement. Keep the total within 110% of the amount specified for capital damages. For theft, keep the police report and any internal incident logs. For loss of use, show how you calculated downtime.

How to Respond to a Code M10 Chargeback

To fight an M10 chargeback, you submit a representment package that explains the facts and proves the charge was valid. Start with a short cover letter that outlines what happened and references the rental agreement. Then include the signed contract page that shows the cardholder’s acceptance of responsibility for capital damages, theft, and loss of use. Highlight any caps or agreed amounts tied to those liabilities.

Add the vehicle handover and return documents signed by the cardholder, along with time-stamped photos showing the condition at both points. Provide an itemised invoice for repairs or replacement parts and at least one repair estimate. Make it clear that the charge did not exceed 110% of the amount the customer agreed to for capital damages. If the case involves loss of use, attach your utilisation records and the method used to calculate downtime. For theft, include a police report or incident number. If you have already processed a credit that offsets the disputed amount, include proof of that credit.

Proactive Prevention: The Ultimate Defence

Prevention starts with clear agreements, careful inspections, and transparent pricing. Train staff to explain liability and optional waivers in plain terms at the counter. Complete a joint walkaround at pick-up and return, with the renter signing the inspection and photos taken on a system that timestamps and stores them. Use realistic repair estimates and provide itemised invoices so customers can see how costs are built. 

Process cancellations promptly and record all requests with dates and times. Build a structured document pack for every incident so evidence is ready if a dispute arises. To react faster when chargebacks occur, try out Chargeback.io to receive early notifications. You can then respond or post a refund before a chargeback is settled against you.

‍